Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- emrp:ws2025:agv [2026/02/27 04:06] – [4.5.2 Automations] 23553_students.hsrw
+++ emrp:ws2025:agv [2026/02/27 21:39] (current) – [4.5.2 Automations] 23553_students.hsrw
@@ Line 42: / Line 42: @@
 Because the current scope uses fans only (no heating/dehumidifier), the system can influence the greenhouse climate mainly by exchanging inside air with outside air. The automation therefore compares inside conditions against outside conditions and only ventilates when outside air is expected to improve the inside climate.
+Although the DHT11 sensors only measure air temperature and relative humidity, these values can be used to calculate the dew point. Dew point is helpful because it is a direct indicator of how close the air is to saturation and therefore to condensation on cold surfaces (e.g., glass), which can promote fungal diseases. In addition, dew point reflects the air’s moisture state more robustly than relative humidity alone, which is temperature-dependent and can appear “high” even when the absolute moisture content is not. This makes dew point a useful metric when deciding whether exchanging inside air with outside air is likely to reduce condensation risk and improve the greenhouse climate.
+<imgcaption image1|>
+{{ :emrp:ws2025:agvdewpoint.jpg?nolink&400 |Dew Point Formula. Source: Own illustration.}}
+</imgcaption>
 Definitions:
@@ Line 53: / Line 59: @@
 Start fans if:
-  * T_in ≥ 29 °C AND T_out < T_in − ΔT
+  * T_in ≥ 29 °C AND T_out < T_in − 0.5%
-Stop fans when:
-  * T_in ≤ 28.5 °C for over 2 minutes
 No humidity/dew point checks here. This is “save the plants” mode.
@@ Line 66: / Line 68: @@
 Start fans if:
   * 27 °C < T_in < 29 °C
-  * AND T_out < T_in − ΔT
+  * AND T_out < T_in − 0.5%
-  * AND DP_out ≤ DP_in + ΔDP_max
+  * AND DP_out ≤ DP_in + 1%
-Stop fans when:
-  * T_in ≤ 26.8 °C for 2 minutes OR outside is no longer favorable
 This allows cooling even if outside dew point is slightly higher, but blocks cases where outside air is much wetter.
@@ Line 80: / Line 79: @@
   * RH_in > 70%
   * AND T_out ≤ 27 °C
-  * AND outside air is truly drier: DP_out < DP_in − ΔDP (or equivalently: absolute humidity outside < inside by a margin)
+  * AND outside air is truly drier: DP_out < DP_in − 0.7%
-Stop fans when:
-  * RH_in < 68% for 2 minutes
-  * OR T_out > 27 °C
-  * OR DP_out ≥ DP_in − ΔDP (outside no longer helps)
 If outside dew point is lower, exchanging air will reduce moisture even if outside is warmer.
+If one of these three conditions is true for 1 minute the fans start, if they are false fo 2 minutes the fans turn off.
 ===== 3. Components =====
@@ Line 147: / Line 143: @@
   * Relay
   * 2x DHT11 Sensors
-<imgcaption image1|>
+<imgcaption image2|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:gardentopdownview.png?nolink&600 |Top down view of garden. Source: Google Maps + Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
@@ Line 170: / Line 166: @@
       * Relay controller
-<imgcaption image2|>
+<imgcaption image3|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:garden_overview.jpg?nolink&800 |Circuit Overview Diagram. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
-<imgcaption image3|>
+<imgcaption image4|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:greenhousecircuit.jpg?nolink&800 |Detailed Greenhouse Circuit Diagram. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
@@ Line 212: / Line 208: @@
 All greenhouse-side electronics (PoE splitter, ESP32, buck converter, breadboard/power distribution, and relay module) are installed in a dedicated enclosure.
-<imgcaption image4|>
+<imgcaption image5|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:greenhouseelectronicsfar.jpg?nolink&800 |Image of greenhouse electronics with descriptions. Source: Own image.}}
 </imgcaption>
-<imgcaption image5|>
+<imgcaption image6|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:greenhouseelectronicsclose.jpg?nolink&800 |Close up image of greenhouse electronics with descriptions. Source: Own image.}}
 </imgcaption>
-<imgcaption image6|>
+<imgcaption image7|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:greenhouseelectronicsclosed.jpg?nolink&800 |Image of greenhouse electronics enclosure closed. Source: Own image.}}
 </imgcaption>
@@ Line 240: / Line 236: @@
     * Installed near the top (remove warm, humid air that accumulates above)
-<imgcaption image7|>
+<imgcaption image8|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:greenhousesideview.jpg?nolink&800 |Side view greenhouse component placement. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
-Because the electronics enclosure is mounted on the greenhouse door while the Ethernet feed and the inside sensor cable are routed to fixed points, both cables are installed with sufficient slack to accommodate the door movement without putting strain on connectors or wiring.
+The electronics enclosure is installed next to the greenhouse door (rather than on the door itself) and remains stationary. The Ethernet feed and the DHT11 sensors are therefore routed to this fixed mounting point, while only the fan wiring requires sufficient slack to accommodate the door’s movement without putting strain on the connectors or cables.
 ==== 4.4 Software setup ====
@@ Line 274: / Line 270: @@
 The initial installation step can require internet access because ESPHome may download required build packages and platform dependencies.
-<imgcaption image8|>
+<imgcaption image9|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:adddevice.jpg?nolink&800 |ESPHome Builder: Add New Device Steps. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
@@ Line 383: / Line 379: @@
-<imgcaption image9|>
+<imgcaption image10|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:registerdevice.jpg?nolink&800 |Register Device Steps. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
@@ Line 402: / Line 398: @@
 To add automatic calculations of the dew points for inside and outside Templates are used. [S3]
-Following the quickling in the Template Documentation or under ''Settings -> Devices & services -> Helpers -> + Create helper -> Template -> Sensor'' we fill in Name, State (shown below), Unit of measurement (°C), Device class (Temperature), State class (Measurement) and select our ESPHome as device. This adds a sensor we can access with ''sensor.<Name>'' that calculates the dew point.
+Following the quick link in the Template Documentation or under ''Settings -> Devices & services -> Helpers -> + Create helper -> Template -> Sensor'' we fill in Name, State (shown below), Unit of measurement (°C), Device class (Temperature), State class (Measurement) and select our ESPHome as device. This adds a sensor we can access with ''sensor.<Name>'' that calculates the dew point.
-<file script inside dew point.txt>
+<file script inside_dew_point.txt>
 {% set T = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_temperature')|float(none) %}
           {% set RH = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_humidity')|float(none) %}
@@ Line 417: / Line 413: @@
 </file>
-<imgcaption image10|>
+A second template is used for checking if the control condition for venting are met. Instead of a ''Sensor'' this is a ''Binary Sensor'' with state:
+<file script should_vent.txt>
+{% set tin  = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_temperature') | float(none) %}
+          {% set tout = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_outside_temperature') | float(none) %}
+          {% set hin  = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_humidity') | float(none) %}
+          {% set dpin  = states('sensor.greenhouse_dew_point_inside') | float(none) %}
+          {% set dpout = states('sensor.greenhouse_dew_point_outside') | float(none) %}
+          {% if None in [tin, tout, hin, dpin, dpout] %}
+            false
+          {% else %}
+            {% set dT = 0.5 %}
+            {% set dp_max = 1.0 %}
+            {% set dp_margin = 0.7 %}
+            {% set extreme_temp = (tin >= 29 and tout < (tin - dT)) %}
+            {% set normal_temp  = (tin > 27 and tin < 29 and tout < (tin - dT) and dpout <= (dpin + dp_max)) %}
+            {% set humidity     = (hin > 70 and tout <= 27 and dpout < (dpin - dp_margin)) %}
+            {{ extreme_temp or normal_temp or humidity }}
+          {% endif %}
+</file>
+<imgcaption image11|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:hascreenshot.png?nolink&600 |Home Assistant Dashboard Screenshot. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
 === 4.5.2 Automations ===
-The ventilation control logic is implemented using Home Assistant automations. This includes temperature-driven ventilation and humidity-driven ventilation rules based on comparing inside vs. outside conditions.
+The ventilation control logic is implemented using Home Assistant automations using the template created in the previous step.
-<imgcaption image11|>
+<imgcaption image12|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:agvcreateautomation.jpg?nolink&800 |Create Automation 1/2. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
-<imgcaption image11|>
+<imgcaption image13|>
 {{ :emrp:ws2025:agvcreateautomation2.jpg?nolink&800 |Create Automation 2/2. Source: Own illustration.}}
 </imgcaption>
 The following YAML file specifies the criteria that Home Assistant uses to determine when to activate the ventilation system based on 2.2 Control concept.
 <file yaml automation.yaml>
-alias: Greenhouse ventilation (temp+humidity instant on, delayed off)
+alias: Greenhouse Ventilation
+description: >-
+  Vent switch follows binary_sensor.greenhouse_should_vent with anti-flip-flop
+  delays.
 triggers:
-  - id: vent_on
+  - entity_id:
-    for: "00:00:30"
+      - binary_sensor.greenhouse_should_vent
-    value_template: >
+    to:
-      {% set tin =
+      - "on"
-      states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_temperature')|float(0) %} {%
+    for:
-      set tout =
+      hours: 0
-      states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_outside_temperature')|float(0) %} {%
+      minutes: 1
-      set hin = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_humidity')|float(0)
+      seconds: 0
-      %} {% set hout =
+    trigger: state
-      states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_outside_humidity')|float(0) %} {{
+  - entity_id:
-        (tin > 27 and tout < 27)
+      - binary_sensor.greenhouse_should_vent
-        or
+    to:
-        (hin > 70 and hout < 70 and tout < 27)
+      - "off"
-      }}
+    for:
-    trigger: template
+      hours: 0
-  - id: vent_off
+      minutes: 2
-    for: "00:02:00"
+      seconds: 0
-    value_template: >
+    trigger: state
-      {% set tin =
-      states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_temperature')|float(0) %} {%
-      set tout =
-      states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_outside_temperature')|float(0) %} {%
-      set hin = states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_inside_humidity')|float(0)
-      %} {% set hout =
-      states('sensor.agv_esp32_greenhouse_outside_humidity')|float(0) %}
-      {% set temp_reason_gone = (tin < 26.8) or (tout >= 27) %} {% set
-      hum_reason_gone  = (hin < 68) or (hout >= 70) or (tout >= 27) %}
-      {{ temp_reason_gone and hum_reason_gone }}
-    trigger: template
 actions:
-  - choose:
+  - target:
-      - conditions:
+      entity_id: switch.agv_esp32_greenhouse_ventilation
-          - condition: trigger
+    action: switch.turn_{{ trigger.to_state.state }}
-            id: vent_on
-        sequence:
-          - target:
-              entity_id: switch.agv_esp32_greenhouse_ventilation
-            action: switch.turn_on
-      - conditions:
-          - condition: trigger
-            id: vent_off
-        sequence:
-          - target:
-              entity_id: switch.agv_esp32_greenhouse_ventilation
-            action: switch.turn_off
 mode: single
 </file>
+To prevent the ventilation system from switching on or off due to brief sensor spikes or small fluctuations around the thresholds, the "on" conditions must be met for one minute and the "off" conditions for two minutes.
 ===== 5. Testing & Validation =====
 ==== 5.1 Test plan ====
@@ Line 516: / Line 518: @@
   * Testing was performed in a bathroom rather than a real greenhouse, so airflow patterns, heat capacity, and leakage behavior differ significantly.
   * The controlled tests mainly covered cases where the “inside” environment was hotter and/or more humid than the “outside” reference. Conditions such as rain events, strong solar radiation, and rapid outside fluctuations were not fully represented.
+  * DHT11 sensors are low accuracy, especially for humidity (often ±5% RH or worse, plus slow response).
-Sensor limitations:
-DHT11 sensors are low accuracy, especially for humidity (often ±5% RH or worse, plus slow response).
 ===== 7. Future Work Ideas =====